Sunday, February 2, 2014

43 cameras, this means constantly 11 people to watch the last is, roughly speaking, more than fifty


Outgoing municipalities right but often "left" (starting with Paris, or Vénissieux) beauche boast CCTV systems beauche they have installed beauche at great expense. The demagogy anime, well, new candidates. There are attempts to impose a consensus. Which is against the video would be lax with crime etc..
However, all studies show that CCTV has very limited effects for very high costs, money that would be much more useful for quality beauche public services, including beauche in terms of prevention and safety. Private companies that install devices, sometimes manage, are the only (major) winners. The creeping privatization of security is also in itself a threat to freedom ... and security.
We publish below two interventions elected communists who argue against the current, facing to the right of Pierre Bedier, former Secretary of State for the privatization of prisons in Mantes-la-Jolie, than Xavier Bertrand, ex-Minister of unemployment, Saint-Quentin. 43 CCTV cameras in Mantes la Jolie: What? - Marc Jammet Councillor PCF
In terms of crime prevention, it is reasonable to doubt. The mare of "Parisian shooter" for two days although he was spotted by dozens of cameras and target all the Parisian police .. while he was asleep in a car shows the total ineffectiveness of such a device in Mantes la Jolie.
In addition to the violations of privacy and civil liberties that such a device can generate, for such a system to be effective, it is necessary "to have someone" behind the screens to identify criminal acts (always in Paris, the testimony of a police officer "that beauche after an hour, you can not see anything" is instructive) .. and staff on the ground - in other words, the number of police present and is likely to respond quickly. beauche
43 cameras, this means constantly 11 people to watch the last is, roughly speaking, more than fifty municipal employees. This is far from the case so far, moreover, that the mayor refuses to communicate this number.
As for actual national police with the support of the constituency of Rosny sur Seine, without actual numbers increase, assuming that criminal acts are identified, one can doubt their rapid response capability.
Except .... the award of grants is not expandable at will. It is precisely in the name of development of CCTV we downsized police. It is precisely because the video is major consumer credit that reduces beauche appropriations for prevention. In other words, what Mantes la Jolie receives for the video, she did not receive any other action, yet they much more useful.
This is the case for the grant of 150,000 euros that will collect Mantes-la-Jolie Interministerial Fund crime prevention as actions to access to justice for all and all are reduced to the bare minimum. beauche
Such a device thus only lead to reassure "cheaply" by weighing a little more about our municipal finances ... before .... these cameras are used to verbalize drivers parking.
There need personal behind the camera (software will do), no need to field staff (PV will be sent directly by post) and it will pay big dividends when the common law - in advance - allowing common to set themselves the fines has been passed.
Of course, it was not in the least to parallel with the video. And you say? In essence, thanks to CCTV, crime down. Why? Because!
Once again, we have to show you (but you know very well), beauche with supporting evidence, of course, you are wasting public money, because the role of CCTV remains marginal when it comes to treatment of delinquency.
Column flights armed hands, robberies, burglaries and vandalism? Oh no, here it increases. +1.6% Since 2009 (that is to say from that video surveillance is deployed and + 6.8% in one year. Deterrent Not really!
On several occasions, the opposition has commissioned a study [5] is conducted on video surveillance in Saint-Quentin, looking very cost

No comments:

Post a Comment